Two for Tuesday - How to Handle Annoying Family Members During the Holidays


Hi Reader,

The holidays are upon us, and this week's post can help you manage your anxiety at family gatherings. Let me know what you think. Thanks for reading.

How to Handle Annoying Family Members During the Holidays

Read on the Blog

The holidays are supposed to be a time of joy and connection, but let’s be honest—family gatherings can also bring stress. We often find ourselves reacting to old patterns with siblings, parents, or extended relatives in ways we’d never tolerate at work. An article in Fast Company reminded me that while we use professional skills to self‑regulate in the workplace, we’re not nearly as good at applying them with family. From a family systems perspective, there are three reasons for this:

  1. The emotional stakes are higher. We worry about damaging relationships, so we’re more likely to react or adapt instead of staying grounded.
  2. We let our guard down. At work, pause before responding. With family, we’ve been together so long that we “just let it rip.”
  3. Old habits are ingrained. Years of repetition hardwire our reactions, making it harder to self‑regulate.

The article suggests approaching family interactions with a blank slate—seeing people anew instead of being triggered by old assumptions. Here are four common types of “annoying relatives” and how to respond in healthier ways.

The Opinionator

This is the relative who insists on debating politics or religion at the dinner table. The temptation is to argue or withdraw, but neither helps. Instead, avoid a conflict of wills. Don’t argue, don’t agree—get curious. Ask questions, listen, and stay emotionally connected without taking the bait. If the conversation becomes impossible, you can respectfully disengage: “I care about you and what you think, but I don’t want to have this conversation right now.”

The Boundary Buster

This person treats you like you’re still twelve, commenting on your clothes, career, or relationships. Sometimes their nosiness masks genuine concern, but often it’s just habit. You can ask, “What makes you ask?” to uncover their motivation—or shut down the conversation if that’s your goal. If curiosity doesn’t help, self‑differentiate: “I appreciate your concern, but I feel confident in my choices.” Define yourself without arguing or agreeing. That’s the essence of being a non‑anxious presence.

The Freeloader

They arrive late, bring nothing, and disappear when it’s time to clean up. Setting expectations in advance helps: “Grandma cooked, so let’s all pitch in afterward.” If you need to make a request in the moment, use nonviolent communication: observation, feeling, need, request. For example: “There’s a lot of cleanup after this great meal. I’m feeling tired and want to wrap things up. Could you help me in the kitchen for a few minutes?” You can’t force them to help, but you can take responsibility for yourself and decide how to handle it next time.

The Pot Stirrer

This relative thrives on drama, gossip, and conflict. The key here is not to engage. You can redirect, listen without debating, or even get playful: “I’m curious to see how this turns out.” Define yourself, don’t define others, and refuse to take the bait.

The big takeaway is that even annoying behaviors are often misguided bids for connection. When you understand this, you can respond with self‑definition and healthy boundaries instead of reactivity. You can say, “I know you care about me, and I care about you too. But I can take care of myself.” That’s how non‑anxious leaders navigate family gatherings—with clarity, compassion, and resilience.

Become a Patron

You can help me improve the quality and reach of this newsletter, my podcast and other resources for as little as $5/month. When you do, you'll get exclusive access to an online community, exclusive content and chat access to get your questions answered. Thanks for your prayerful consideration.

Recommendations

This week we have a Kathleen Smith two-fer, just in time for the holidays.

The Overfunctioner's Holiday Edition! - by Kathleen Smith This article helps you understand how focusing on the functioning of others drains your energy, as well as what you can do about it.

The Underfunctioner's Holiday Edition! - by Kathleen Smith This one shows how you may be inviting others to overfunction, then provides some reflection questions to think about how to show up differently.

Podcast

Episode 361 of The Non-Anxious Leader Podcast, Leadership through Self-Differentiation (Part 3 of 4) – The Problem with Seriousness and Reactivity (Rebroadcast), is now available.

That's it for this week. Thanks for reading.

Peace,

Jack

P.S. If you are new to Two for Tuesday, you can read previous editions HERE.

P.P.S. If this was forwarded to you by a friend, you can subscribe here.

Jack Shitama

I show faith-based leaders how to be a non-anxious presence, personally and professionally.

Read more from Jack Shitama

Hi Reader, Another week, another Tuesday. This week's post can help you move from reactive or adaptive responses to healthy emotional connection. I hope it helps. From Fight or Flight to Connection: Five Steps to Self‑Regulation Photo: knorre Read on the Blog Self‑regulation is the ability to manage your own anxiety when tensions rise. It’s not about suppressing feelings or pretending everything is fine—it’s about staying grounded enough to respond in a healthy, intentional way. This Harvard...

Hi Reader,Happy Giving Tuesday! This week's post explains why generosity is good for your well-being. I hope you find it helpful. It IS Better to Give than Receive Photo: RVAS Read on the Blog When I started as a camp director in 2000, I didn’t think I’d be a fundraiser. By the time I left in 2023, much of my job was about raising money. One thing I’ve learned is that asking people for money is actually doing them a favor. Why? Because it IS better to give than receive. Except when it’s not...

Hi Reader,It's Thanksgiving week for those of you in the U.S. Regardless, gratitude and self-differentiation go together year-around. If nothing else, please read (and follow) the opening quote. You'll be glad you did. Enjoy! Emotional Connection and Gratitude Read on the Blog “And I urge you to please notice when you are happy, and exclaim or murmur or think at some point, ‘If this isn’t nice, I don’t know what is.’” — Kurt Vonnegut My wife and I once attended a wedding reception where we...